Why Are You Calling it an Accident When it Was Preventable?

After our segment on CTV Morning Live on July 9, 2014, a viewer emailed Brenda Hollingsworth to comment that all this talk of “accidents” was misplaced.  All the boating and swimming pool incidents we were discussing were not accidents, he argued, but preventable events.  Some clients have a similar reaction when we refer to their motor vehicle collision as an accident.

Here is Brenda’s explanation. You may or may not agree.

First, “motor vehicle accident” is a term of art.  All of the precedents, legal treaties, police paperwork etc, refer to motor vehicle accidents or MVAs.  Basically, the use of the word “accident” is so prevalent in my business that it rolls off my tongue without too much thought.  I did try to use motor vehicle collision for a while, but it didn’t stick.  In the U.S., many of the personal injury lawyers I know refer to car accidents as car “wrecks”.  That is certainly descriptive, but too harsh or graphic for me.

Second, when lawyers say “accident” what we mean is that the negligent actor / at-fault person / defendant did not INTEND to cause harm.   We sue for negligence.  We don’t prosecute intentional crime or assaults when we represent injured people in our office.  Our compensation model in Ontario focuses on the degree of injury to the victim, not the degree of fault or moral culpability of the wrong doer.  You don’t get more money if the accident was easliy preventable.  The quantum of damages is based on the severity of the victim’s impairments, assuming the other party caused the injuries.

From my perspective, the fact that an incident was preventable does not mean it wasn’t an accident.  Most accidents are preventable.  We spend a lot of time in our newsletter and on our website promoting safety and accident prevention.

What do you think?  Should we scrap the term accident? What word should we use instead?

    100% Free Case Review
    Speak with a lawyer directly.
    Learn what steps you can take next.
    1-888-574-4529
    You do not need any documents or medical records on hand for this call.
    No fee, and no commitment.

    Case Type*

    Did you suffer any physical, psychological, or cognitive injuries?*

    Did your accident occur in Ontario?*

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
    Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    By submitting this form, you agree to receive follow-up communications pertaining to your inquiry, and marketing emails. Information submitted will be transmitted to a law firm. This communication is intended to be an attorney-client communication for purposes of evaluating your claim and will be kept confidential by the law firm. The communication does not create an attorney-client relationship and no relationship is formed until a fee agreement is signed by you and the law firm. Our privacy policy can be found here.



    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.