Case Overview

A man suffered a concussion and a herniated disc in his lower back after his vehicle was struck from the side by a driver attempting a left turn. The force of the T-bone collision caused extensive vehicle damage, resulting in his car being declared a total loss.

Despite his injuries, the client returned to his military employment with modified duties and workplace accommodations.

Auger Hollingsworth lawyer Gillian Mactaggart represented the injured driver in his personal injury claim. She gathered persuasive independent medical examination (IME) reports and witness statements from the client’s military superior officers and family members to demonstrate how the accident affected his health, employment and daily life.

Through thorough case preparation and effective negotiation, Gillian successfully secured a $500,000 settlement at mediation.

How We Built a Winning Case

Gillian Mactaggart represented a man who was seriously injured when another driver attempted a left turn and struck his vehicle from the side. The impact was severe enough that his vehicle was written off.

The collision left him with a concussion and a herniated disc in his lower back. Although he returned to work in the military, he required accommodations and modified duties because of his injuries.

Gillian focused on documenting the extent of his injuries and demonstrating how the collision affected his ability to work and manage everyday activities.

Establishing the Impact of the Left-Turn Collision

Left-turn accidents can cause serious injuries, particularly when one vehicle strikes another from the side.

In this case, the client’s vehicle sustained extensive damage and was declared a total loss. He suffered a concussion and lumbar disc herniation that affected his physical functioning and ability to perform his regular duties.

Gillian built the claim around the client’s medical evidence, work limitations and the consequences of the collision.

Building Strong Medical Evidence With Independent Examinations

Medical evidence played an important role in demonstrating the extent of the client’s injuries.

Gillian obtained persuasive independent medical examination (IME) reports to support the claim. These reports provided professional medical assessments of the client’s condition and the impact of his injuries.

This evidence helped strengthen her position during settlement negotiations.

Demonstrating Workplace Limitations Through Military Superior Officers

Although the client returned to military employment, he was unable to resume all his usual duties without accommodations.

Gillian obtained will-say statements from his military superior officers to help establish how his injuries affected his work responsibilities.

These statements provided firsthand evidence of the changes to his duties and the accommodations required following the collision.

By documenting these limitations, Gillian demonstrated that returning to work did not mean the client had fully recovered.

Documenting the Impact on His Daily Life

In addition to medical assessments and workplace evidence, Gillian obtained will-say statements from the client’s family members.

These statements helped illustrate how the concussion and lower back injury affected his life outside of work.

The combination of medical evidence, workplace observations and family testimony provided a more complete picture of the consequences of the collision.

Securing a $500,000 Settlement at Mediation

With persuasive IME reports and supporting statements from the client’s military superior officers and family members, Gillian presented a well-supported claim during mediation.

The evidence demonstrated the seriousness of the injuries and their impact on the client’s ability to perform his regular activities and employment duties.

Gillian successfully negotiated a $500,000 settlement at mediation, resolving the personal injury claim without requiring a trial.

This result highlights the importance of detailed medical evidence and firsthand witness testimony when pursuing compensation for injuries that continue to affect a person’s life, even after returning to work.

Key Case Takeaways

  • $500,000 Settlement Secured: Gillian Mactaggart successfully negotiated a $500,000 settlement at mediation for a driver seriously injured in a left-turn T-bone collision in Ontario.

  • Concussion and Herniated Disc Injuries: The client suffered a concussion and lumbar disc herniation in a collision that left his vehicle written off. He returned to military employment but required modified duties and workplace accommodations.

  • Strong Medical and Witness Evidence: Persuasive independent medical examination (IME) reports and statements from military superior officers and family members helped demonstrate the impact of the client’s injuries on his employment and daily life.

Frequently Asked Questions

Drivers making left turns must ensure they can complete the manoeuvre safely and comply with applicable traffic laws.

A driver who fails to yield to oncoming traffic or makes an unsafe turn may be found responsible for a collision.

However, liability depends on the circumstances of each accident, including traffic signals, vehicle movements, speed and other available evidence.

Yes. If you suffer a concussion in a motor vehicle accident caused by another driver’s negligence, you may be entitled to compensation.

Concussions can cause headaches, dizziness, memory problems, fatigue and difficulties concentrating. Some people experience symptoms that continue for months or longer.

Compensation depends on the medical evidence, severity of symptoms, recovery progress and applicable legal requirements.

Yes. A herniated disc caused or aggravated by a motor vehicle collision may support a personal injury claim.

A lumbar disc herniation can cause lower back pain, restricted movement and symptoms affecting the legs. Some injuries require ongoing physiotherapy, medication or other medical treatment.

A personal injury lawyer can help document the injury and its effects on your daily life and ability to work.

Yes. Returning to work does not automatically prevent you from pursuing compensation for accident-related injuries.

You may still experience pain, reduced physical capacity, limitations on your regular job duties or ongoing rehabilitation needs.

In this case, the client returned to military employment with modified duties. Evidence from his superior officers helped demonstrate how the accident continued to affect his ability to work.

Witness statements can provide evidence about how an injury has affected a person’s work, daily activities and quality of life.

Statements from employers, supervisors, family members or others familiar with the injured person may help demonstrate changes in their physical abilities and daily functioning.

In this case, statements from military superior officers and family members supported the medical evidence and helped establish the consequences of the client’s injuries.

An independent medical examination is an assessment conducted by a medical professional who evaluates an injured person’s condition.

IME reports may address the nature of the injury, functional limitations, treatment needs and ability to return to work.

These reports can be important evidence in personal injury claims, particularly when the severity or ongoing effects of an injury are disputed.

Mediation is a process in which the parties work with a neutral mediator to explore a possible settlement.

The mediator does not decide the case. Instead, the mediator helps the parties discuss disputed issues and negotiate a potential resolution.

If an agreement is reached, the claim may be resolved without proceeding to trial.

Speak With an Ontario Car Accident Lawyer

If you or a loved one suffered a concussion, herniated disc or another serious injury in a left-turn collision, you may be entitled to compensation.

Contact Auger Hollingsworth today for a free, no-obligation consultation. Our car accident lawyers can review your case, explain your legal options and help you pursue the compensation you deserve.

Helpful info, delivered to you—free!

Sign up for our free monthly newsletter. It’s full of useful info (plus occasional giveaways). You can unsubscribe anytime.