Case Overview
A woman nearing retirement age suffered a concussion and chronic neck and back pain after falling ice from a metal roof struck her head at a commercial property. The impact caused her to fall to the ground, leaving her with injuries that required ongoing physiotherapy and massage therapy. Her condition prevented her from returning to work.
Gillian Mactaggart of Auger Hollingsworth represented the injured woman in her personal injury claim. The case involved two insurance companies, including one that denied liability entirely and refused to offer compensation until just months before trial.
Through persistent litigation and thorough trial preparation, Gillian successfully secured a $400,000 settlement for her client.
How We Built a Winning Case
Gillian Mactaggart represented a woman who suffered serious injuries after ice fell from the metal roof of a commercial building and struck her head. The force of the impact knocked her to the ground, causing a concussion and persistent neck and back pain.
Her injuries required regular physiotherapy and massage therapy treatments. They also affected her ability to work, ultimately preventing her from returning to employment as she approached retirement.
Gillian pursued compensation for her client’s injuries, ongoing treatment needs and resulting financial losses.
Building a Strong Premises Liability Claim
Commercial property owners and occupiers in Ontario have legal responsibilities to take reasonable steps to keep their premises safe.
Gillian pursued a premises liability claim arising from ice falling from the commercial property’s metal roof. The case required addressing the responsibilities of the parties involved and the circumstances surrounding the incident.
Challenging an Insurer’s Denial of Liability
The claim involved two insurance companies, which made settlement negotiations more complicated.
One insurer maintained a zero-liability position and refused to offer compensation for most of the litigation. This position continued until the case was only a few months away from trial.
Rather than accepting the insurer’s refusal to negotiate, Gillian continued pursuing the claim and preparing for court.
Maintaining Pressure Through Trial Preparation
Gillian took a proactive approach to litigation and maintained pressure as the trial approached.
She continued advancing the case through several important procedural steps:
- Requests to admit: Formally requiring the opposing parties to admit or deny specific facts or documents.
- Document productions: Pursuing the disclosure of relevant records and evidence.
- Notices of motion: Taking procedural steps to advance contested issues before the court.
- Trial preparation: Continuing preparations to present the client’s case at trial if a reasonable settlement could not be reached.
These efforts demonstrated that Gillian and the Auger Hollingsworth legal team were prepared to proceed to trial rather than accept an inadequate outcome.
Securing a $400,000 Settlement Before Trial
Despite an insurer’s continued refusal to accept liability, Gillian Mactaggart maintained pressure through requests to admit, document productions, notices of motion and ongoing trial preparation.
Her persistent approach helped bring the parties to a resolution, ultimately securing a $400,000 settlement just months before trial. The outcome provided compensation for a client whose injuries had prevented her from returning to work as she approached retirement.
The settlement resolved the claim without requiring the client to proceed through a full trial.
This case highlights the importance of thorough preparation and persistent legal advocacy when insurers dispute responsibility or refuse to make reasonable settlement offers.

























