When “Low Contingency Fees” Could Cost You More

If you have been injured in an accident, it is natural to look for the best legal representation at the best value. Some personal injury lawyers in Ontario advertise lower contingency fees to attract clients. While that may sound appealing, it can be misleading. In some cases, a lower fee percentage results in a much lower settlement—and far less money in your pocket.

At Auger Hollingsworth, we want you to make informed decisions. Here is what you need to know about contingency fee percentages and why “cheaper” is not always better.

A Lower Percentage Can Mean Lower Effort

Personal injury law is not just about filing paperwork. It is about building a strong case, retaining medical and financial experts, gathering evidence, and negotiating from a position of strength. This level of service takes time, effort, and resources.

Lawyers offering a significantly lower contingency fee may be running high-volume practices. Their business model depends on settling as many cases as quickly as possible. That often means accepting the first offer from the insurance company—even if it is well below what your case is worth.

In contrast, a personal injury law firm that charges a slightly higher fee but puts in the work to secure a higher settlement can leave you much better off financially.

Let’s Look at the Math

Here is an example:

• Lawyer A charges 20 percent and settles your case for $50,000.
  You receive $40,000 after fees.
• Lawyer B charges 30 percent but settles your case for $200,000.
  You receive $140,000 after fees.

In this example, Lawyer B may seem more expensive, but you end up with over three times more money.

The difference is not just in the fee percentage. It is in the value the lawyer brings to your case and how seriously the insurance company takes them.

Reputation and Resources Matter

Insurance companies know which lawyers settle cheap and which ones are prepared to go to trial. If your lawyer is known for avoiding court, the insurer is less likely to offer full value for your claim. A law firm like Auger Hollingsworth, with a strong reputation for trial readiness and successful outcomes, puts pressure on insurers to treat your case seriously.

We also invest in expert reports, life care plans, and vocational assessments to ensure we understand the full impact of your injuries. This results in higher compensation, especially in serious or long-term cases.

ALSO READ: Why the Personal Injury Lawyer You Choose Matters

The Real Cost Is What You Take Home

When considering a law firm, focus on what you will receive—not just what they charge. Ask how they approach settlements. Do they go to trial? Will they spend the time needed to maximize your compensation?

Value Over Price

At Auger Hollingsworth, we believe in earning our fee by delivering results. Our clients know that we do not cut corners and we do not chase quick payouts. We aim to get you the compensation you need to recover, rebuild, and move forward with confidence.

Call us today for a free consultation. Let’s talk about your case, your options, and what real value looks like.