What Insurance Companies Think of Your Lawyer’s Reputation

When you are involved in a personal injury claim, you may assume that your case will be judged solely on the facts—your injuries, your expenses, and how your life has been affected. But there is another factor that has a significant impact on your claim: the reputation of your lawyer. Insurance companies in Ontario know which lawyers are likely to build a strong case and hold out for fair compensation, and which ones will settle quickly for less.

At Auger Hollingsworth, we have earned a reputation for going the distance. That reputation benefits every client we represent.

Your Lawyer’s Track Record Speaks Volumes

Insurance companies and defence lawyers handle thousands of personal injury claims every year. They keep detailed notes on the law firms they deal with. They know which firms rarely go to trial, which ones are overextended with too many files, and which lawyers are thorough, well-prepared, and unafraid to stand up in court.

If your lawyer is known for quickly settling cases at low values, that history can work against you. The insurance company may assume they can offer a lowball settlement and your lawyer will accept it. On the other hand, if your lawyer has a track record of pushing cases to discovery, mediation, and trial when needed, the insurer is much more likely to treat your claim seriously.

The Insurance Industry Values Strategy and Follow-Through

An experienced personal injury lawyer does not just gather medical records. They work with specialists, economic experts, and treatment providers to build a compelling case. When insurers see this level of preparation, they know they are not dealing with a file that will quietly disappear.

At Auger Hollingsworth, we prepare every case as if it is going to trial. That does not mean every case ends up in court, but it does mean the other side knows we are ready. This approach often leads to higher settlement offers because the insurer wants to avoid the time and cost of a legal battle they may not win.

Reputation Can Increase Your Settlement

We have seen first-hand how two similar cases can have very different outcomes based on who is representing the injured party. In one example, our firm achieved a million-dollar settlement for a client in a multi-vehicle accident. Another victim in the same accident, represented by a less experienced firm, received only $50,000. The difference was not the injuries—it was the representation.

Choose a Firm the Insurance Companies Respect

At Auger Hollingsworth, we are known by name across Ontario’s insurance industry. Our lawyers are respected for their professionalism, thoroughness, and results. We do not fold under pressure. We fight for fair compensation, and we know what it takes to get it.

If you want a team that insurers take seriously, call us today for a free consultation. Your case deserves to be treated with the seriousness it warrants—and that starts with choosing the right lawyer.